Saturday, October 15, 2011

A slap on the wrist and one in the face

Daniel Saylor
Ex-Police Chief Daniel Saylor faced the music yesterday. He stood before Judge Jeffrey Arnold in Orange County courtroom 10A, awaiting his sentence for two counts of Official Misconduct, one count of Solicitation to Commit Official Misconduct and one count of Solicitation to Tamper with Physical Evidence.

Unfortunately, the music was too soft and easy.

By all accounts, Saylor presented himself as a man of character who had done many good deeds in his life.

Scott Bush
By all accounts, perhaps, except that of the child victim whom he failed to protect from his buddy Scott Frederick Bush. Bush is currently out on bond, awaiting trial for two counts of Sexual Battery Victim <12 yrs old, and one count of Lewd/Lascivious Molestation Victim <12.

Saylor's cover up of an investigation into his friend's alleged crimes was not only his undoing, but caused a maelstrom that included lawsuits, a scuffle at a Town Council meeting, and governmental shakeups in the formerly quiet town of Windermere (well, as long as you don't talk about Tiger Woods' "incident" it was quiet).

Saylor's attorney, Mark NeJame, argued that his client had suffered great public embarrassment; loss of his job, his law enforcement certification, and numerous friends (though many were in the gallery to support him); and was truly remorseful.

Please pass the Kleenex.

In reviewing numerous press reports about Mr. Saylor's misconduct, it is obvious that his 1-yr jail sentence (with work release approved by the judge), is like slapping someone on the wrist with a feather. At the time of his arrest, there were over 1,000 pages in FDLE's investigation of Winderemere's police chief. In addition to allegations relating to Bush, Saylor allegedly:

  • Accepted a $1000 cash "gift" in 2010 from Raul Carvajal, a subordinate, who sought to have a friend hired by the police department (Carvajal pled no contest to one count of bribery and one count of official misconduct, and was sentenced to 1 day in jail, 3 years probation and 150 hours community service earlier this month - adjudication was withheld);
  • Failed to take action when DNA testing identified a suspect in a 2004 home invasion and attempted kidnapping case three years ago;
  • Returned a diamond tennis bracelet that had been stolen from police evidence. Additionally, over 20 guns, drugs, cash, and other valuables had reportedly disappeared from the less than secure evidence room.
  • Filed false crime statistics.
  • Voided tickets for residents and government employees.
  • Ordered officers to drive intoxicated residents home rather than arrest them for DUI.
  • Used officers to disperse immigrant workers at Bush's home after they had nearly completed work for him then refused to pay them.
  • Sold guns meant for law enforcement to civilians.
Additionally, Saylor
  • Resigned from the Melbourne Police Department in 1996 after being stopped in Orlando with a prostitute; and
  • Was suspended from the Florida Police Chiefs Association in 2009 for "misbehaving" at a conference, unbeknownst to Windermere's government.

With all of that, I find Judge Arnold's comment to Saylor, "You're a talented man and will recover from this blip in the middle of your life" extraordinarily inappropriate. See it here.

This "blip?"

Did he call it a "blip?"

How can one call misconduct and criminal behavior going back 15 years a "blip?"

I call it disgraceful - both Saylor's behavior and the comment made by the judge.

And a one year sentence with the judge's permission to do work release? A slap in the face to Bush's victim, law abiding citizens, and good cops everywhere.

Sunday, October 2, 2011

DV Awareness Month begins with fatality

purple ribbonOctober is Domestic Violence Awareness Month 

Domestic Violence is often thought of as being limited to intimate partner relationships. But the legal definition encompasses all relationships where one family member assaults another.


This past weekend I had the honor of commemorating those who lost their lives in Orange County by reading their names at the DV Task Force's event at Lake Eola. They are listed here.

If you review the names, you'll notice that of the 19 fatalities from October 2010 through September 2011, there were 6 children. 

We celebrate that the total number of DV deaths in Orange County dropped from 28 in the previous year to 19. But children are comprising a greater percentage of fatalities, rising from 14% to 32%.

And on the first day of DV Awareness Month, a former law enforcement officer, Timothy Allen Davis Sr,  shot and killed his adult son in an argument over his grandchild just a few hours after our event.

So the Orange County fatality list has a new name for next year's DV Task Force walk. And another family has forever been changed by domestic violence.

That should sadden us all. 

Thursday, September 29, 2011

It Takes Courage: Walk for Awareness



The Orange County Domestic Violence Task Force kicks off Domestic Violence Awareness Month with a Walk at Lake Eola on Saturday, October 1st from 9:00 am until 10:30 am at the amphitheater. 

Please join us and learn more about the efforts in our community to eliminate DV, honor its victims, and connect with Task Force member agencies.

Here is a list of the 13 adults and 6 children who have lost their lives since last year's event:

10/6/2010
Alfonso Angelo Tapia (8 wks)
Perpetrator: father
Weapon: not disclosed

10/9/2010
Jill Morris
Perpetrator: boyfriend
Weapon: gun

10/11/2010
Jacob Carmichael
Perpetrator: romantic rival
Weapon: gun

11/15/2010
Christobal Escontrias
Perpetrator: girlfriend
Weapon: stabbed

11/17/2010
Malloree Tatum (6 mo)
Perpetrator: mother's boyfriend
Weapon: shaken baby

11/19/2010
Jaliya Rivera (4 mo)
Perpetrator: father
Weapon: shaken baby

2/2/2011
Jason Rodriguez
Perpetrator: romantic rival
Weapon: gun

3/3/2011
Thelma Carter
Perpetrator: Husband
Weapon: gun

3/3/2011
Noah Fake (3 yrs)
Perpetrators: mother & mother's BF
Weapon: blunt force trauma

3/16/2011
Fabiana Romero
Perpetrator: Estranged husband
Weapon: gun

4/3/2011
Rosa Barrientos Isalgue
Perpetrator: estranged husband
&
Raymond Treasure
Perpetrator: romantic rival
Weapon: gun

4/9/2011
Ruth Owino
Perpetrator: fiancé
Weapon: hand weight

5/28/2011
Tramaine Griffin
Perpetrator: romantic rival
Weapon: gun

6/30/2011
Carry Dorcelus
Perpetrator: children’s father
Weapon: gun

7/19/2011
Pamela Carr
Perpetrator: Husband
Weapon: gun

7/27/2011
Phillip Peatross
Perpetrator: girfriend
Weapon: gun

7/29/2011
Isaiah Shade (2 yrs)
Perpetrator: Mother's boyfriend
Weapon: blunt force trauma

8/29/2011
Bonnie Marie Caban-Pearce (5 mos)
Perpetrator: under investigation
Weapon: not disclosed

Monday, September 19, 2011

A trio of fatalities in 24 hours

Domestic Violence Awareness Month begins in less than two weeks. If you're not aware of DV in our community after this weekend, you must be living under a rock (either that, or you've been on jury duty for the Bob Ward murder case and therefore not allowed to view any news media).

Most people think that domestic violence only happens to lower income, uneducated people. Think again. The past two days in Central Florida should forever dissuade us from that notion.

Early morning, Sunday, September 18, 2011

Victim:
Beatrice "Bea" Dickey, 44, murdered at home in Plant City

Alleged Perpetrator: Lawrence Douglas Dickey, husband
Weapon: baseball bat

Click here for the Lakeland Ledger's coverage


Bea Dickey's murder is perhaps what most of us think of when we hear a story about a domestic fatality. I wonder, though, did anyone at the Polk County Sheriff's Office suspect she might be a victim? 



Even though she was surrounded by law enforcement personnel at work, did she feel safe to disclose what was happening at home? Do the people she worked with know how to recognize domestic violence "warning signs" and how to refer their friend & co-worker to get assistance? Does the Sheriff's Department have a standard policy for dealing with domestic violence amongst its employees?
It is highly unlikely that we'll ever know the answers to most of these questions. But I hope that Ms. Dickey's death will make those closest to her ask them and formulate solutions to prevent a similar tragedy in the future.

Sunday morning, September 18, 2011

Victim: Theresa Fogle, 56, murdered at home in Lakeland
Alleged perpetrator: Jeremiah Fogle, husband, subsequently opened fire and wounded two pastors at the couple's former church nearby
Weapon: gun

Orlando Sentinel's coverage dated  9/18/11 and 9/19/11

It has been reported that Mr. Fogle pled to manslaughter in the death of another wife, Diane, 25 years ago and was only sentenced to probation for that crime. 


This tragedy highlights

  • Abusers come from "good" families.
  • There are abusers in religious institutions, often in prominent positions (Fogle was a deacon in his church).
  • Abusers usually have many victims in their past (Fogle was married 7 times).
  • The court system is often ineffective in how it handles perpetrator accountability, particularly in domestic violence cases.
  • Domestic violence doesn't happen only in private. The church members who witnessed Mr. Fogle's shooting rampage were undoubtedly traumatized by his actions.
  • Churches, like businesses, need policies in place for dealing with domestic violence.

Approximately 10:00 AM, Monday, September 19, 2011

Victim: Heidi Shelmire, 38, murdered at Burger King, her place of employment, in Debary
Alleged Perpetrator: Jesus Morales, ex-boyfriend
Weapon: gun

Click here for the Daytona Beach News Journal report on this case
Click here for WFTV's report

This tragedy highlights several "cracks" in the system:
  • An injunction is not bulletproof. It only works if the respondent respects the law and is afraid of going to jail.
  • Just because an injunction prohibits the respondent from having a firearm, it doesn't mean he or she will comply.
  • Victims of dating/domestic violence need a safety plan when leaving a relationship. For some, an injunction might not be advisable. They need to seek assistance from trained advocates at their local DV shelter.
  • Domestic/Dating violence doesn't happen only in private. Ms. Shelmire's co-workers and the patrons at the store were undoubtedly traumatized by Morales' actions.
  • Employers need a comprehensive DV policy for the workplace. 
  • For whatever reason, the perpetrator was not arrested for violating the injunction on previous occasions. If the victim called for help when he violated the injunction, I hope law enforcement takes a long, hard look at why the court order was not enforced.
Do you suspect someone at your workplace, school, church or neighborhood might be a victim of domestic violence? Don't  know how to help? 


Start the conversation with "I'm concerned about your safety" and help them get connected with a trained advocate to do a safety plan. Victims tend to feel completely isolated and embarrassed about their situation. Tell them it's not their fault and that there are people who can help.


You might just save a life.

Tuesday, July 19, 2011

Whatever happened to. . . ? #30

The following cases were all dismissed, dropped or nolle prossed.

Orange County

David Michael Huffman
2010-CF-018047-A-O
L/L Exhibition (2cts)
Defendant, a homeless sex offender, allegedly flashed a girl <12 yrs old at the Dollar Tree in Apopka


John Earl Huntt
2010-CF-018041-A-O
Possess Material Depicting Sexual Performance by Child (11cts) 
Defendant has been a professional photographer for more than 20 years


Karen D Cerezo
2010-MM-002717-B-O
Battery DV 
Defendant and her friend, former Deputy Belinda Mills, allegedly assaulted defendant's ex-husband. Mills was accepted in pretrial diversion; Defendant was rejected from pretrial diversion program


Melissa Ann Scivoletti
2010-CF-011725-A-O
Kidnapping; False Imprisonment; Force/Coerce Another to Prostitution 
Defendant allegedly befriended the victim online, offered her a job at Wal-Mart, brought her to Pennsylvania and then Orlando with another co-conspirator where victim was forced to comply w/their demands


Neil Abraham Ramroop
2010-CF-014687-A-O
Kidnapping; Robbery; Battery DV; Tamper w/Witness Hinder Comm w/LEO 
Defendant allegedly kidnapped the mother of his children from VCC, threatened to kill her family, and assaulted her. See earlier blog regarding this case.


Michael Wilson
2010-CF-010245-A-O
Sexual Battery (Coerces Victim) 3cts 
Defendant allegedly raped a woman in a field behind a fire station near Heritage Park


Michael Reichert
2007-CF-010491-A-O
Possess Material Depicting Sexual Performance by Child (114 counts) 
Defendant is a former UCF professor who claims a  virus downloaded images onto his computer


Rosa Marie Pou
2010-CF-017909-A-O
Neglect Elderly/Disabled Adult w/o Great Harm; Resist Officer w/o Violence
Defendant allegedly abandoned her disabled teenaged son at Sea World's play area for 2+ hours


Marc W Blazejowski
2010-CF-005167-A-O
Aggravated Battery; Felony Battery 
Defendant, a police officer in CT, is charged with choking his pregnant fiancee at Disney


Robert Jonathan Walyus
2010-CF-017915-A-O
Agg Stalking of Minor
Defendant was a janitor at McDonalds in Oviedo and allegedly exposed himself to a teen at the restaurant


Leon Chisholm
2011-MM-004010-A-O
Battery DV
Defendant's girlfriend, Melissa Johnson (2011CF5835) was allegedly attempting to get away from defendant before he was released from custody for this charge. Johnson's 14-yr old daughter was killed in a DWI crash.


Michael Thomas Henderson
2011-CF-006109-A-O
L/L Molestation Victim 12-15yrs; Video Voyeurism; Solicitation of Minor via Computer
Defendant allegedly used his volunteer position in his church's puppet ministry to meet and have inappropriate contact with his victim


Luis Gonzalez-Santiago
2010-CF-016010-A-O
Attempted Sexual Battery; Burglary of Dwelling w/Assault or Battery; Attempted Armed Burglary of Occupied Dwelling; Attempted Burglary Occupied Conveyance; Stalking; False Imprisonment; Battery DV  
Defendant allegedly attacked a woman he used to live with after she drove him to meet his probation officer




Seminole County


Durand Brown
2010 CF 004144A
Neglect of Child
Defendant, a teacher at Eustis Middle School, was arrested after his 1-yr old son was found wandering alone wearing only a soiled diaper


Jeremy Decker
2010 CF 005223A
Kidnap / False Imprisonment; Possess Marijuana; Sexual Battery; Possess Drug Paraphernalia
Defendant & co-defendant Sarah Hand allegedly picked up a distraught woman, took her to their home, and sexually assaulted her


Sarah Hand
2010 CF 005223B
Kidnap / False Imprisonment; Possess Marijuana; Sexual Battery; Possess Drug Paraphernalia
Defendant & co-def Jeremy Decker allegedly picked up a distraught woman, took her to their home, and sexually assaulted her


Ronald Jackson
2010 CF 004994C
Lewd/Lascivious Battery Victim 12-15yrs old 
Defendant & co-defs Joshua Gibson & Tracy Johnson allegedly gave a 14-yr old girl alcohol & marijuana, then sexually assaulted her


Aaron Floyd
2011 CF 002263A
Sexual Battery
Defendant, a student at UCF, allegedly assaulted a woman he met online at match.com & forced her to go to a pharmacy &  take a 'morning after' pill


Timothy Cash
2011 MM 001091A
Assault DV
Defendant, a Windermere police officer with a history of misconduct while employed by OCSO & Kissimmee PD, allegedly threatened to kill his wife after drinking heavily.